Clarence Thomas Issued a Warning About What California Can Now Force You to Say

Krakenimages.com via Shutterstock

In 2018, the Supreme Court told California it couldn't force pro-life pregnancy centers to advertise abortions.

California found a workaround, and on Monday three justices warned it now threatens every licensed professional in America.

Clarence Thomas came one vote short of stopping it and left a nine-page list explaining exactly who comes next.

California's DEI Mandate Forces Doctors to Teach Implicit Bias or Lose Their Medical License

California passed a law in 2019 requiring every licensed physician to include "implicit bias" instruction in mandatory continuing medical education courses every two years.

Dr. Azadeh Khatibi teaches those courses in ophthalmology – eye medicine, not sociology, not racial equity theory, not systemic racism in healthcare. She disagreed that implicit bias is the primary driver of healthcare disparities and refused to include it.

California's answer: comply or lose your medical license.

Khatibi and the nonprofit Do No Harm sued, arguing that forcing a private instructor to deliver a government-approved message on a contested topic is textbook compelled speech under the First Amendment.

The Ninth Circuit disagreed.

Their reasoning was simple and dangerous: California regulates the medical profession so heavily that any instruction required for a medical license automatically becomes "government speech" – which means the First Amendment doesn't apply to it at all.

Regulate a profession heavily enough and the government owns every word spoken inside it.

One Trump-appointed Ninth Circuit judge called it "state-sanctioned groupthink" in the en banc dissent.

The Supreme Court majority let that ruling stand, declining to hear the case – Thomas and Alito dissented.

Thomas Named Every Profession California Can Force Into DEI Compliance Next

Thomas wrote nine pages on what the Supreme Court just greenlit – and he warned about California was doing.

"What of other professions whose members California licenses and regulates?" he wrote. "At the next statewide legal conference at which lectures are offered for continuing legal education, could California require a keynote speaker to oppose racial preferences in law firm hiring?"

Thomas wasn't speculating – that was the logical endpoint of the Ninth Circuit's ruling.

Under that logic, any state that licenses a profession – medicine, law, engineering, accounting, counseling – can mandate exactly what licensed professionals say in professional settings.

An engineer teaching a licensed professional development course would need to include the state's preferred messaging on climate policy. A counselor teaching other counselors would affirm gender ideology as settled science, or lose the license that lets her practice.

Thomas went further: "It cannot be the case that compelled speech becomes government speech because the government has compelled the speech."

This isn't the first time California tried this playbook. In 2018, the state told pro-life pregnancy centers they had to post notices advertising nearby abortion clinics – classifying it as professional regulatory speech exempt from First Amendment scrutiny.

The Supreme Court struck it down in NIFLA v. Becerra.

California came back with a different theory – instead of calling it "professional speech," they reclassified it as "government speech." The Ninth Circuit accepted that rebranding, and Thomas described it as using the government-speech doctrine "a cover for censorship" or "a cloak for compelled speech."

Justice Neil Gorsuch also indicated he would have granted certiorari, noting his dissent separately without joining Thomas's written opinion. That's three justices – Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch – and four are needed to take a case. They came up one vote short.

Other states have followed California's lead, passing similar implicit bias mandates for licensed professionals. They're all watching what California just got away with.

The government-speech doctrine was designed for one narrow purpose: letting governments articulate their own positions without being forced into false neutrality.

California turned it into a weapon. Regulate a profession heavily enough, then classify every private instruction delivered under that license as "government speech" – and the First Amendment disappears for every licensed professional in the country.

Thomas warned his colleagues that the Court's own precedent doesn't support this result, and neither does the Constitution.

Chief Justice John Roberts Roberts, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett were each appointed to stop exactly this kind of government overreach. All three passed, joined by Justices Jackson, Sotomayor, and Kagan – though nobody expected the Left side of the Court to fight for free speech.

Thomas left nine pages in the record explaining what comes next.

Sources:

  • Robert Schmad, "Clarence Thomas calls foul on California ruling he says could turn citizens into government mouthpieces," Fox News, November 16, 2026.
  • Justice Clarence Thomas, dissenting, Khatibi v. Yip, No. 25-1240 (U.S. Nov. 17, 2026).
  • Thomas A. Berry, Brent Skorup, and Alexander Xenos, "Khatibi v. Lawson," Cato Institute, May 15, 2026.
  • Pacific Legal Foundation, "PLF asks the Supreme Court to affirm that licensure shouldn't come at the expense of free speech," Pacific Legal Foundation, 2026.

Total
0
Shares
Previous Article

Forensic Expert Found Something in Epstein Autopsy Photos That the FBI Missed

Related Posts