Thom Tillis just told reporters he couldn't care less about angering President Trump.
Now the top Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee is calling him and John Cornyn brave.
Two outgoing Republicans have found a way to hand Democrats the judgeships they lost at the ballot box.
The Blue Slip Blocking Trump's Federal Judge Nominations in the Lame Duck
Senate Republicans are in the final weeks of their majority before Democrats take control of the chamber in January.
Trump has judicial nominees ready to fill lifetime seats with conservatives who will interpret the law the way his Supreme Court justices do.
Miss this window and those seats sit empty until the next Democrat in the White House fills them.
The only thing standing between Trump and those confirmations is a procedural trick two outgoing senators are using as a weapon.
The blue slip is a century-old unwritten Senate tradition – home-state senators withhold a form from the Judiciary Committee and a judicial nominee dies without ever getting a vote.
Chuck Grassley killed the blue slip for circuit court nominees back in 2017 but has refused to extend that reform to district court nominees, and that gap is now costing Trump the bench.
Twenty-three nominees are waiting with only 20 Senate session days left – confirming all of them would require more than 200 hours of floor time, a math problem Senators Thom Tillis and John Cornyn have no interest in solving.
Cornyn has refused to submit a blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser – Trump's nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas who leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, the office that issued the legal opinions powering Trump's most aggressive policy actions – which means Gaiser can't even appear before the Judiciary Committee.
In Oklahoma, outgoing Sen. Alan Armstrong initially supported Zach West – a lawyer in the state attorney general's office whose work on pro-life cases and religious charter school rights made him a favorite among conservative legal groups – then reversed course and pulled the blue slip, with Tillis immediately backing that reversal to leave West short of the committee votes he needs.
Before either of those nominations, the White House was already forced to withdraw Judge Lee Rudofsky's nomination to the 8th Circuit entirely after Tillis helped Arkansas senators kill it.
Three nominees dead or withdrawn because two senators decided their personal grudges with the White House mattered more than cosnervatives on the bench.
Why Senate Republicans Are Running Out of Time to Confirm Trump's Judges
Grassley has protected the blue slip for district courts while openly acknowledging it gives individual senators veto power over the president's picks.
Tillis posted publicly last year that eliminating the blue slip would "pave the path for Democrats to ram through extremist liberal judges in red states over the long-term" – the same path he is now paving himself.
Senate Majority Leader John Thune waited until the final weeks of the Republican majority to prioritize judicial confirmations, then discovered there wasn't nearly enough floor time left to confirm half the backlog.
Republicans have been treating judicial confirmations as an afterthought all year, and that scheduling failure just became expensive.
One piece is still fixable: Armstrong leaves the Senate on November 30, replaced by Senator-elect Kevin Hern, who could return a favorable blue slip for Zach West and flip the committee votes before Christmas – though that only saves one of three blocked nominees.
Cornyn's pattern here is nothing new – he went rogue on the Todd Blanche nomination back in July, blocking a committee vote for weeks to extract concessions from the Justice Department.
Dick Durbin – top Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee – publicly praised Cornyn and Tillis for showing more courage than their Republican colleagues.
When Dick Durbin is calling Republicans brave for blocking Trump's judges, those senators stopped working for Trump and started working for Schumer.
George Mason law professor Rob Luther – who worked on judicial nominations inside the Trump White House Counsel's Office during the first term – said senators on "borrowed time" are standing directly in the way of movement conservatives reaching the federal bench.
Trump has confirmed 58 judges this term, pushing roughly one-third of all active federal judges into Trump appointments, and every seat Cornyn and Tillis block stays empty until the next Democrat president fills it with someone designed to undo that work.
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer made clear after the midterms that Democrats have no intention of confirming what he called Trump's "crappy nominees" once they take the gavel in January.
Cornyn lost his Texas primary to Trump-backed Ken Paxton earlier this year, which means he has nothing left to lose – and right now he's burning the house down on his way to the parking lot.
Sources:
- Cullen Linebarger, "As Clock Ticks on Confirming Trump's Judicial Nominees, These Three RINOS Are Determined to Ensure That Some Never Get Approved," The Gateway Pundit, November 15, 2026.
- Tyler Durden, "Lame-Duck Republicans Sabotaging Trump's Judicial Confirmation Blitz," ZeroHedge, November 16, 2026.
- Ashley Oliver, "Trump Nominees Squeezed Between Blue Slips and Blue Obstruction," Fox News Digital, August 31, 2025.

